During a renovation of their bathroom in 2008, Frank and Kathy Hollingsworth found a letter and two envelopes beneath their cast iron bathtub. The letter, to a Rose O'Connor, is dated July 20, 1920 and has an envelope that goes with it and shares that date. The second envelope is to a Jim O'Connor and is dated over a year later. The letter is from a man named "Will" who didn't include his last name.

​

Over the years the Hollingsworths have speculated what the letter could have been about and whether the second envelope has any connection to the letter.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Read the transcript for Part 1.

​

Special thanks to the Hollingsworth Family for their help with this episode.